Owning a home in Minnesota comes with plenty of responsibilities. Between maintaining your roof, preparing for winter, keeping up with repairs, and managing everyday expenses, homeowners insurance can easily become something you purchase and rarely think about again.
But insurance isn’t necessarily something you can set and forget.
Your home changes over time. Construction costs increase, belongings accumulate, and insurance policies can change at renewal. Meanwhile, Minnesota weather continues to bring everything from summer hailstorms to heavy snow and freezing temperatures.
Unfortunately, some of the most common homeowners insurance mistakes don’t become obvious until someone needs to file a claim.
Understanding these potential problems can help you make better decisions about your coverage. Here are seven mistakes Minnesota homeowners should avoid and what to consider instead.
One of the biggest home insurance mistakes is assuming your home’s market value is the amount you should insure it for.
Market value and replacement cost are not the same thing.
Market value reflects what a buyer might pay for your property, including the land and other real estate factors.
Replacement cost reflects what it would take to rebuild your home using comparable materials and construction methods.
Those numbers can be significantly different.
Imagine your home could sell for $350,000, but rebuilding it after a major fire would cost $425,000.
If your dwelling coverage isn’t sufficient, you could face substantial out-of-pocket expenses.
Construction labor, materials, building codes, and other rebuilding costs can change over time.
The Minnesota Department of Commerce recommends reviewing your policy regularly to make sure your coverage reflects the cost of rebuilding.
What to do instead: Review your dwelling coverage amount and ask how your insurer calculates replacement cost. If you’ve made significant improvements, make sure they’re reflected in your policy.
Everyone appreciates saving money, especially when household expenses continue to increase.
However, choosing Minnesota homeowners insurance based solely on the lowest monthly or annual premium can create problems.
Two policies with similar prices may provide very different coverage.
One might offer replacement cost coverage for certain losses, while another applies depreciation. One might include additional protection for water backup, while another requires an endorsement.
Deductibles, exclusions, and coverage limits can also differ.
When comparing homeowners insurance policies, consider:
A lower premium isn’t necessarily a bad choice. The important thing is understanding what you’re receiving for that price.
What to do instead: Compare coverage details alongside premiums so you’re evaluating the overall protection rather than just the cost.
Water damage is one of the most misunderstood areas of homeowners coverage in Minnesota.
Many homeowners assume that if water damages their house, homeowners insurance will automatically pay for repairs.
Unfortunately, different sources of water can be treated very differently.
For example, a sudden plumbing failure may be covered under certain circumstances, while gradual leakage or damage resulting from poor maintenance may be excluded.
Standard homeowners insurance also generally does not cover flooding caused by rising surface water.
Another common source of confusion involves sewer and drain backups or sump pump failures.
These losses may require additional coverage.
The Minnesota Department of Commerce specifically recommends reviewing water backup and sump pump protection because homeowners policies may not automatically include them.
This can be particularly important for Minnesota homes with basements.
What to do instead: Ask how your policy handles plumbing leaks, sewer backups, sump pump failures, groundwater, and flooding. Consider whether additional endorsements or separate flood insurance are appropriate.
Minnesota homeowners are familiar with unpredictable weather.
Strong winds, hailstorms, heavy snow, and severe thunderstorms can damage roofs, siding, windows, and other parts of a home.
But one of the most overlooked property insurance mistakes involves deductibles.
Some homeowners policies have separate deductibles for wind and hail damage.
These may differ from the deductible that applies to other covered losses.
Suppose your home is insured for $400,000 and your policy has a 2% wind and hail deductible calculated using that insured value.
Your deductible would be $8,000.
That could be a significant surprise if you expected to pay only $1,000 or $2,000.
The Minnesota Department of Commerce advises homeowners to review storm deductibles and watch for policy changes that may narrow coverage.
What to do instead: Check whether your policy has a separate wind or hail deductible and understand exactly how that amount is calculated.
Your house may be your largest investment, but it probably isn’t the only valuable part of your property.
Many Minnesota homeowners have detached garages, storage sheds, pole buildings, workshops, and other structures.
Standard homeowners policies commonly include other structures coverage, but the available limits may not be sufficient for every building.
For example, a large heated garage may cost substantially more to rebuild than the amount provided under your standard other structures limit.
It’s also easy to underestimate the value of everything inside your home.
Furniture, electronics, clothing, appliances, tools, jewelry, and recreational equipment can add up quickly.
Certain high-value belongings may have special coverage limits.
And motorized vehicles such as ATVs, snowmobiles, or boats may require separate insurance.
What to do instead: Review your other structures and personal property limits. Create a home inventory and ask whether valuable items or recreational equipment need additional coverage.
Homeowners insurance isn’t just about protecting buildings and belongings.
It also generally includes personal liability coverage, which may help protect you financially if you’re legally responsible for covered injuries or property damage involving someone else.
For example, a visitor could slip on an icy walkway or suffer an injury on your property.
Depending on the circumstances, your homeowners liability coverage may respond to a covered claim.
However, liability limits vary.
Certain property features and activities deserve additional attention, including:
Some policies contain exclusions or restrictions involving these situations.
For homeowners with substantial assets or additional liability exposure, an umbrella policy may also be worth discussing.
What to do instead: Review your liability limits and tell your insurance professional about property features or activities that could affect your coverage.
Perhaps the easiest mistake to make is assuming that once you’ve purchased homeowners insurance, your coverage will always remain appropriate.
Life changes, and so does your home.
You might replace your roof, finish a basement, remodel a kitchen, build a detached garage, or purchase expensive equipment.
Your insurance company may also change certain policy terms or deductibles at renewal.
Without reviewing those changes, you could develop insurance coverage gaps without realizing it.
An annual review is a good starting point.
You should also consider reviewing coverage when:
The Minnesota Department of Commerce recommends reviewing homeowners insurance annually, particularly as coverage terms and storm protection can change.
What to do instead: Treat your insurance review as part of regular home maintenance, just like servicing your furnace or preparing your property for winter.
An under-insured home is one where the available insurance may not be enough to cover a significant loss.
You don’t necessarily need to experience a claim to recognize potential warning signs.
Consider whether:
Being under-insured doesn’t always mean having a policy with a low dollar limit. It can also mean missing an important type of coverage or misunderstanding how a particular loss would be settled.
A policy should reflect your actual property and risks rather than simply remaining unchanged year after year.
Before your next policy renewal, take a few minutes to review the basics.
These steps won’t prevent every unexpected event, but they can help you better understand the protection you have.
Homeowners insurance is an important financial safeguard, but the value of a policy depends on how well it matches your needs.
The most common homeowners insurance mistakes often involve assumptions: assuming your home is insured for enough, assuming all water damage is covered, assuming every deductible is the same, or assuming a policy never needs updating.
For Minnesota homeowners, those assumptions can become particularly costly when severe weather, freezing temperatures, or unexpected property damage occurs.
Understanding replacement costs, reviewing exclusions, keeping an inventory, and checking coverage annually can help reduce the likelihood of unpleasant surprises.
National Insurance Brokers – Hice Agency is an independent insurance brokerage serving the Brainerd Lakes area and other Minnesota communities. Working with multiple insurance carriers allows the agency to help clients compare coverage options and understand how different policies may fit their circumstances.
The goal isn’t necessarily to purchase more insurance. It’s to understand what you have, identify meaningful gaps, and make informed decisions about protecting your home.
For questions about Minnesota homeowners insurance, coverage limits, deductibles, or other property insurance needs, National Insurance Brokers – Hice Agency provides guidance for current and prospective clients.
National Insurance Brokers – Hice Agency
8175 Industrial Park Rd, Suite 2
Baxter, MN 56425
Phone: 218-203-5540
Email: info@insuredbaxter.com
Additional locations are listed in Grand Rapids, Longville, and Remer, Minnesota.
At National Insurance Brokers, your privacy is our priority. We will never sell, share, or distribute your personal information to third parties. The information you provide is used only to connect you with one of our expert brokers to help find the best coverage for your needs. Your data is kept secure and confidential at all times.
By submitting this form and signing up for texts, you consent to receive text messages from National Insurance Brokers at the number provided, including automated messages and messages related to Customer Care. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Msg & data rates may apply. Msg frequency varies. Unsubscribe at any time by replying STOP or clicking the unsubscribe link (where available). Reply HELP for help.
Privacy Policy: https://insuredbaxter.com/privacy-policy/
Terms and Conditions: https://insuredbaxter.com/terms-and-conditions/